skip to Main Content

Ignoring Immigration History Lesson – And Repeating Its Mistakes?

Those who fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it.
– Winston Churchill

A vexing issue for decades, Immigration is now causing extreme measures, including President Trump’s government shutdown and national emergency declaration.

Let’s revisit 2013, when the bipartisan Senate “Gang of Eight” came close to finding compromise solutions.  Meaning solutions nobody was HAPPY with – but everybody could LIVE with.

Eight prominent senators, four Democrats (Bennet-CO, Durbin-IL, Menendez-NJ, Schumer-NY) and four Republicans (Flake-AZ, Graham-SC, McCain-AZ, Rubio-FL) hammered out a comprehensive Immigration bill that passed the Senate 68 – 32.  Fourteen Republicans joined Democrats in passing it.

Other Republicans didn’t vote for it because in some states, Immigration is the Third Rail of politics:  touch it and you die (meaning a primary challenger claiming you’re “soft on Immigration”).

Noteworthy that John McCain, the “Moderate Maverick” who died last year, was an instrumental voice in attempting to reach across the aisle.

Why didn’t this bill become law?  Because Republican House Speaker John Boehner, facing rebellion from Tea Party hard-liners, refused to act on it; so it expired.  As Immigration became more partisan in recent years, few serious attempts addressed it – and none came close to resolving it.

Since this bipartisan effort came closest to success, let’s review its provisions:

  • A path to citizenship for illegal immigrants already here, contingent on border security improvements. Permanent residence only AFTER legal immigrants receive permanent status.

This provokes intense reactions, as opponents scream “AMNESTY” at terrified politicians.  But it included border security improvements, which everybody agrees we need, and could have avoided Trump’s shutdown and national emergency declaration.

  • Immigration system reforms, reducing visa backlogs, fast-tracking permanent status for university graduates in STEM fields (science, technology, engineering, math).

We need these immigrants’ skills in our high-tech economy, to compete globally in technology advancements.  So this benefits us as well as them.

  • Expanded, improved verification systems to ensure all employers confirm their employees’ authorization to work in the U.S.

A dirty little secret.  Employers fill difficult jobs Americans won’t take (landscapers, roofers, maids, dishwashers, among others) by hiring undocumented immigrants.  Many remain illegally “in the shadows”, paying no taxes, vulnerable to abuse by unscrupulous employers and criminals.  With more monitoring of these workers, they would pay taxes and employers would legally fill jobs.

  • Better visa options for low-skilled workers, including agricultural workers.

Farmers need workers to pick vegetables and fruits in harvest seasons.  Without immigrants, produce would rot in the fields, bankrupting farmers.  Food prices would skyrocket.  Again, this would benefit us, not just immigrants.

Since this bill readily passed the Senate six years ago (and might have passed the House if given a chance), why not use it as a starting point now?

What’s needed to resolve this issue, once and for all?

One, politicians with courage, standing up to extremists in their parties blocking compromise solutions, such as this one.

Two, Americans accepting reality, actively supporting legislators who compromise with the other side.

Too much to hope for?  Maybe, at least with extremists on both ends of our political spectrum.  But the rest of us, especially Modern Moderates, must embrace compromise as our only hope – and DEMAND it from our leaders.

Community Guidelines

The Modern Moderate welcomes readers’ ideas and discussions of issues. We do insist, in Moderate fashion, that comments should be as respectful and informed as possible, to keep our site constructive for our readers. Therefore, posts deemed hostile, obscene, untrue, or misleading will be deleted, and authors of those comments may be blocked from posting comments in the future. Thank you for your cooperation.

Share Your Thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top